Contribute as
a Guest Author
Check the details
arrow button
Created on November 16, 2026 | Updated on November 16, 2026

Max Roslyakov: “DR and DA Are Vanity Metrics” & Other Interview Highlights

Expert Interviews
Max Roslyakov: “DR and DA Are Vanity Metrics” & Other Interview Highlights

Max Roslyakov interview bio

These are highlights from our interview with Max Roslyakov. You can learn more about Max’s work on FatGrid or connect with him on LinkedIn.

Note: Max Roslyakov has conducted research on backlink price inflation, analyzing 44,821,814 backlink price records.

Backlink prices are rising. That's probably the biggest trend and the shortest answer.

The longer answer is…

SEO and link building are growing a lot, even with AI. Demand is growing, but backlink inventory isn't growing much. That’s why we see rising backlink prices.
  • The market is bad in one sense: prices are growing.
  • But it's good in another: more people will see an opportunity to earn money from content projects.

So, I think we're fine. This is just the market developing over time.

I can give you many examples of websites that rank without backlinks:

  1. If the market knows who you are, your opinions can rank.
  2. If you build useful tools on your website, those pages can rank without links. Sometimes Google doesn't even display AI Overviews for those queries, so you get traditional blue-link results.
  3. You can also rank without links in a unique niche that no one else covers.
  4. Or for hyperlocal queries where only a few businesses operate in the exact location.
There are plenty of examples where you can rank without backlinks. What becomes difficult without links is competing in a crowded niche. That's when they become important.

But even then, it's not about building a certain quantity every month.

First, Google's guidelines do prohibit buying links to manipulate rankings. That's a real rule.

But the broader economics are more complicated.

Even when you earn a placement through outreach, you still pay for content creation, outreach time, and sometimes an editorial fee.

We do a lot of outreach for organic backlink placements, and in my experience, almost none of those activities are truly free backlinks.

People run websites as businesses.

I believe you should start by creating genuinely strong content, then reuse and repurpose it for guest posts, link insertions, and other distribution

There's no such thing as completely free link building. You're paying either for someone's time or for a service.

Besides, I've also researched marketplace publishers' outgoing links and the organic performance of sites receiving them.

In the vast majority of cases I checked, organic performance improved. Meaning that those links work.

But…

A more expensive link isn’t always better. After all, price and value aren't the same thing.

We often earn placements through manual outreach on pages that already rank in Google.

A publisher may refresh an already-ranking page, add our link, and then rank even better. Our client may benefit from a link on a relevant page that Google already values.

Sometimes you can get that for a couple of hundred dollars.

How to allocate a $10,000 SEO budget these days

Before you do any SEO, make sure your website actually works. I'm not kidding: I've seen people try to buy traffic for a site that visitors couldn't even open.

So, first, do the basic checks. These can be free. You can use the free versions of Semrush, Ahrefs, or Screaming Frog.

Second, clearly explain what your business does. Hire a copywriter if necessary. Shoot a short video. Create a few well-written blog posts to expand on the topics covered by your main page.

No matter what you do for SEO, it ultimately ends with a real person visiting your website. So it needs to be able to convert. It has to be clear who the website is for, what it offers, and why the company has expertise. All of that should happen before promotion.

Now, for the $10,000.

I'm biased because I work with backlinks, but I wouldn't spend the whole budget on them.

I'm a big fan of short, inexpensive experiments with Facebook and Google Ads.

Allocate a couple of thousand dollars to test whether the website, content, and offer actually convert. Send relevant traffic to different pages and see how people behave.

Once you know the website converts, you need more traffic.

You can continue some paid acquisition and invest in long-term organic growth. That's where backlinks come into play.

When doing SEO, first, prove you can get conversions with small PPC tests. Second, rank in the top 50 without links. Once you're in the top 50, use links to improve rankings.

This is usually the most expensive part, so I'd allocate about half the budget to it.

If I had a $10,000 SEO budget, I’d spend $2,000 to make the website look good, convert, and have enough content. About $3,000 for paid ads to test keywords and landing pages. And $5,000 for link building.

This order matters.

We once had a client who spent $15,000 promoting AI slop. To some extent, that was my fault. After nearly three months of doing what we were hired to do, building links, the results were unusually weak.

I finally read the content we were promoting carefully. Shame on me. The problem wasn't just the links. It was the content itself.

SEO for an established website

At an established company, start with technical checks:

  • For a small site, free versions of Semrush, Ahrefs, or Screaming Frog may be enough.
  • For a larger site, pay for a tool and run a deeper audit. Check page speed, internal linking, broken links, redirects, and other obvious issues. The crawl itself shouldn't take a whole week. Then sit down with a developer and fix the most serious problems.

Next comes the content audit.

That can be technically complicated, but it's extremely important.

On an established site, creating new articles without reviewing existing content often causes keyword cannibalization. You cover topics that were already covered before, and if the old pages weren't ranking, the new pages may struggle too.

I usually look for quick wins because, in a real job, management wants to know that hiring you was a good decision.

Refreshing existing content is often faster and cheaper than creating new articles. And in my experience, you can often gain more traffic for less money that way.

This is how I’d approach it:

  1. Open Google Search Console,
  2. Compare the last three or six months with the previous period, and identify pages that used to perform well but have lost organic traffic.
  3. Ask your writers or contractors to update those pages.

Once the technical and content foundations are in place, you can move ahead with link building.

Why DA and DR often do more harm than good

DR and DA are vanity metrics that have very little to do with a link’s actual value. What many underestimate, though, is contextual relevance, which matters far more.

DR and DA are still industry standards, and people rely on them, but I've repeatedly shown how easy they are to manipulate.

You can pay someone on Upwork or Fiverr around $50 to raise a site's DR to 50 or 60.

A domain authority score can be useful for quick benchmarking. It helps you eliminate obviously weak sites and create a first-pass filter. But the details really matter.

In fact, when I first built my product, I didn't include DR.

But eventually I had to accept that it's an industry standard. People want to see it. You can tell them a million times that it's a misleading vanity metric, but you still have to build a product customers want to use.

And for the record, I'm a paying Ahrefs customer. I think it's a very good tool overall, even though I really dislike DR.

I've debated this publicly with people at Ahrefs, including Patrick Stox. My position isn't necessarily that they should remove DR, but that they should improve it.

I'm a strong supporter of Semrush Authority Score for one simple reason: it includes organic traffic. It's not perfect. But…

Imagine a site with a stable backlink profile that loses nearly all its organic traffic after a Google update. From my perspective, that site is now much less attractive for placements.

Semrush reflects traffic in its score, while Ahrefs argues that DR should measure backlinks alone.

I understand the distinction, but if a metric can be manipulated so easily, what value does it really have?

When choosing websites for backlinks, I start with budget. Then I look at organic traffic and its trend. After that, I check contextual relevance, regardless of language or region. Finally, I manually review the site.

But of course, everyone has their own ideal workflow. Here is what I do in detail:

  1. I start with the obvious constraint: budget.
  2. After that, there are several possible paths, but I focus mainly on organic traffic and its trend. I usually filter for sites with at least 1,000 estimated monthly organic visits, according to Semrush or Ahrefs.
  3. Then I check contextual relevance: does this website make sense for the client I'm promoting? That's the core of it.
  4. Finally, I manually review the website. There are obvious signs of low quality, such as ads everywhere, but sometimes it's simply a judgment call: does the site feel legitimate or strange?

I can also tell you what I don't pay much attention to.

Unlike many SEOs, I don't rule out a site simply because it's in a different language or region.

I've repeatedly seen contextually relevant placements on French or Spanish websites help American clients.

Don't underestimate placements in other regions. They can work.

I care more about whether the site's traffic is stable than which country provides most of its visits.

Are PBNs a thing of the past?

Traditionally, a PBN was a group of low-quality blogs owned by one person. That model worked years ago, but it doesn't work well now.

At the same time, I see people running 10 or 15 legitimate content blogs. They:

  • hire writers,
  • publish articles,
  • run ads,
  • and operate much like a traditional affiliate business.

Technically, it's still a network of blogs owned by one person to make money. You could call that a PBN.

But here is the thing…

The problem with PBNs is their terrible reputation. But if there is a legit site that meets every quality requirement for a good placement, its ownership structure isn't what matters. Still, would the PBNs from 10 years ago work today? No way.

So this is partly a question of reputation and terminology. But what really matters is the quality of the site and the relevance of the link.

We've seen up to 5% of backlinks disappear or change after publication. So the important question is what happens to your article and link after the placement process is finished. That's where most problems occur.

Some links become nofollow.

Others are blocked in robots.txt, at the page level, or even at the paragraph level.

Sellers or website owners who don't care about their reputation may try to preserve 'link juice' by quietly removing links that buyers already paid for.

When it comes to scaling, my biggest signal is whether you have your standard operating procedures (SOPs) in place. If you scale before defining and documenting your processes, you end up with chaos.

SOPs are boring, and nobody loves writing them, but they're essential.

Suppose you've handled the technical issues, set up content production, started building links, and traffic is improving.

You're ready to scale only when the process is documented well enough for someone else to follow. For instance:

  • An existing assistant should be able to train two new assistants, potentially tripling output.
  • Or you could build an AI agent and delegate a clearly defined part of an SOP to it. I'm a big believer in AI agents and build many myself, but I'd put the process in place first.

The other requirement is understanding the math: return on investment (ROI).

You're paying people to create content and do outreach. Their work helps pages rank, traffic brings in leads and customers, and those customers generate revenue. If you can measure that chain credibly, you can start investing more.

But I'm not a fan of increasing link-building budgets indefinitely just to build more links.

When you reach higher positions, you might need some ongoing effort to maintain them. Keep part of the budget for supporting links, but move the rest toward new topics, pages, or product areas that can drive business results.

I don't like offers such as '20 DR 60+ links every month.' Someone who understands their business shouldn't treat a backlink package like that as a strategy.

Your actual goal is to earn money.

If organic traffic produces leads, demo bookings, calls, and new customers, increasing the investment may be justified.

The number of links isn't a meaningful business KPI by itself. I've seen a couple of good links move rankings substantially, and they weren't always the most expensive. Focus on the outcome, not the process metric.

Where SEO budgets get wasted

Most SEO budgets get wasted on silver bullets. Businesses love anything that promises quick results without much work, even if it costs thousands.

Right now, AI visibility trackers are a good example. In my view, many are little more than interfaces built on the ChatGPT or Anthropic APIs and sold at a huge markup.

We've also discussed AI content-generation products.

There are more exotic offers, such as services promising to influence Google autocomplete suggestions, which may charge significant fees without really moving the needle.

I also think many SEO audits are overpriced or not especially useful.

I've hired agencies that wanted to begin with a $5,000 audit. In many situations, a good initial action plan for the next two or three months should cost closer to $500 or $1,000.

So, the real answer is:

If you want to save your SEO budget, avoid supposed magic solutions and be skeptical of expensive audits that don't lead to clear, practical next steps.

The hype around AI-backed SEO services

In a market driven by hype, selling a product can be easier than building something that delivers on its promises.

I still help friends with their small businesses, and every month someone forwards me another 'magic' tool or workflow.

Sometimes they've already started a trial and want my opinion.

Before getting any SEO software, I suggest testing the claims by looking at the vendor's own website. If a product promises to dominate search, why doesn't the company itself rank?

SEO professionals can open Semrush and check the traffic in a few moments.

But a plumber or accountant buying an SEO service may not know how to evaluate another website. They see a plausible promise and buy it.

That's the market.

Does Google see everything?

I do believe Google sees everything. The better question is: does Google care? And often it doesn't.

Google may know about many of the things people worry about, but it doesn't necessarily care about them. That's the important distinction.

Does AI-generated content work for SEO?

There's a lot of hype around AI-generated content.

Some companies sell 'perfect' AI content generators, while others say AI content doesn't rank.

Interestingly, I've checked the websites of many people selling AI-generated content, and their own websites often don't rank.

But I don't think the problem is AI-generated content as such. It's content quality.

People think Google can reliably detect AI-written content. I doubt that. What it can detect is low-quality content. Because so much AI content is slop, people confuse the two. But the real issue is quality.

I'm not a native English speaker, so when I write something, I often dictate my notes or blog posts to ChatGPT and ask it to correct the grammar.

Those posts are sometimes flagged as AI-generated even though the ideas and the original words are mine.

From a rankings perspective, I've never noticed a difference between posts prepared that way and posts I typed myself.

What's important is adding new knowledge to your content.

Content should offer a unique perspective that makes it worth citing and ranking.

The problem with most AI-generated writing is that it rephrases existing information. But if you have a distinct opinion, unique data, or original research, you can generate much of the text around those insights.

You can also ask AI tools to stop overusing em dashes and negative framing. Tell people what something is, not endlessly what it isn't.

The point is that…

AI-written content itself isn't the problem. A lack of expert perspective, interesting ideas, or unique data is the problem.

No.

I don’t think AI will kill link building. I think AI can automate a lot of the process, but it won't simply eliminate the need for links.

Algorithms can change. Sure.

If Google announced tomorrow that backlinks were no longer an authority signal, much of traditional link building could disappear.

But I think that's unlikely. I've heard Google engineers explain how difficult it would be to replace links as a signal.

These are highlights from our Adsy Talks podcast with Max Roslyakov. For more insights, watch the full interview on our YouTube channel:

Disclaimer
The website is not affiliated with, sponsored by, or endorsed by the companies mentioned in the reviews, unless explicitly stated otherwise.
All trademarks, logos, images, and materials are the property of their respective rights holders.
They are used solely for informational, analytical, and review purposes in accordance with applicable copyright law.
More Like This
Comments
Do you want
a call back?
Leave your number and one of our
professionals will contact you
0 letter(s) | 15 minimum
* Required
Example: +44 208 068 24 78
Thanks!
Your dedicated manager
will get in touch soon.